MirabellaBlack Magic Marker Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, Long-Lasting Smudge-Proof Matte Black Eyeliner with Felt Brush-Tip for Precise Controlled Application and Antioxidants Vitamin C and E

This is my favorite and it’s so hard to fine

My friend game me this eyeliner 6 yrs. Ago. I don't wear it everyday and only wear it on eyelid..goes 9n smooth and perfect line! Just ordered a new one last week. Never dried out Excellent Eyeliner

I've been trying to find a good cruelty free eyeliner and I definitely found one! At first it seems like it doesn't work great, but then it's incredible how well it works after a couple of times. You do need to let it dry for a little bit cus if you're like me and you put an emo level accessive amount of eyeliner on, it does stick together when you open you're eye all the way. Otherwise, it's perfect. Super smooth and comfy. Love it!! Also IA super easy to take off, but is definitely water proof and smudge proof

Ordered this for my wife several times in the past and it always lasted for several months, this time it only lasted for one month and was used only a few times, disappointed for the price expected better, won't order again.

More than likely this is the eyeliner you have been looking for. I have purchased this product three times over the last three years. It lasts forever so don't let the price affect your decision. It stays so fresh that I didn't even realize that I have had the one I am presently using for over twelve months! It is still working pretty good but I thought it might work a little better if I purchased a new one. Duh! A year sure does go by in a blink! I give it five stars because I haven't found anything better. It is so close to what I am looking for in an eyeliner. It stay on most of the day. I am able to draw fine, medium lines and if you're looking for thick lines it will enable you to draw those as well. I highly recommend this eyeliner!

I do really like this eyeliner. However, it’s the third time I have purchased it, and the first one, 5 years ago, was better. More consistent coverage.

I like this product because I can actually draw a fairly even line with it (I, generally, don't do well with eyeliner). It has a nice fine tip and goes on quite smoothly. It stays on well, on my top lash line, but I find I do have to reapply to my bottom lash line later in the day. It may be that II smear concealer over the bottom lash line and the liner can't adhere well.

I do a fairly dramatic winged eyeliner everyday for many many years now, and of all the eyeliners I've used this is my favorite. It goes on easily, the point is not too small, not too big. The color is solid and smooth and lasts forever! If I dont wash my face at night it still looks perfect the next morning. Does not smear or wear off easily! As long as they keep making this eyeliner it's all I will buy.